In the Blooming Grove, the tiefling wandered around happily and curiously, the others wondering if he was still the same person.

As he was dealt his final blow, Lucien grabbed his own chest and ripped it apart, possibly implying that the sliver of Mollymauk still within him was helping to destroy him.

He took "The Ice Spinner" as his stage name, likely due to his ability to summon ice with his blood. After the battle, Caleb used his Transmuter's Stone to cast Raise Dead on Lucien's body, seeking to bring back Mollymauk. The tiefling then joined the rest of the group as Caduceus cast Plane Shift, and they all headed to the Blooming Grove. In game, Molly didn't remember anything from his past, leaving fans to believe that The Mighty Nein could still stumble onto pieces of his backstory.

This seemed to cause Lucien pain, prevented him from completing attacks against them, and made him lose Legendary Actions, strongly suggesting that Molly's memories and personality still existed within him. I don’t want to remember anything, I don’t want anybody else’s baggage in my head, I don’t want anybody else’s problems, thoughts, ideas… I like this person, right now, is a good person, is a fine person, is a happy person. Upon meeting Cree in the Evening Nip and being addressed as Lucien, Mollymauk panicked and insisted that the Mighty Nein play along. The Nine Days of Av are a religious observance in Judaism that takes place during the first nine days of the Jewish month of Av.Caleb included a stained glass window in the library of his nine-sided tower that was reminiscent of Mollymauk's signature coat. According to Toya (who had been the most recent member when he arrived), Molly didn't talk properly when he first joined the carnival, [26] constantly repeating the word "empty".

Wanting to scam the scammer, Mollymauk and the carnival traveled there, with the tiefling pretending to be the duke of Ashtania, a member of the non-existent royal family. The next morning, Jester cast Greater Restoration on him, and he regained the ability to speak and think for himself. Molly has a light Irish accent [12] while apparently in his previous incarnation of Lucien it was much more prominent. Taliesin had hoped that Molly could continue coming up with new lies about his backstory for a long time, but was forced to come clean during the events of " Fleeting Memories" (2x14). Mollymauk's has innate magical capabilities, "blood has all the power", which he inherited from Lucien and didn't need to master to be able to wield them.At one point Mollymauk gave another tarot reading to a client who wanted to start a new life in Nogvurot, and shortly thereafter, Molly heard rumors that the lawmaster of Nogvurot who claimed to be well connected with a royal family from the distant lands, which was considered to be false and created to justify his abusive government. Molly learned tarot reading from Lestera, who also spent time talking and drinking together, which brought them closer together. Later, under a Zone of Truth, Molly revealed his amnesia and desire to live as a new person separate from whoever Lucien may have been.

It is revealed in Critical Role: The Mighty Nein - The Nine Eyes of Lucien that Lucien had a younger sister, Aldreda, and a niece, Marii. Five Soda Maximum by chaya - Someone asked for: High school AU with Molly and Caleb, each wishing they had the guts to ask the other to prom. He was introduced as a promoter for the carnival, a "fortune-teller", and "the Ice Spinner", a stage name given to Molly due to his ability to summon ice using hemocraft during his performances. His coat had been left behind, found twenty feet from the gravemarker and left to the elements until it was retrieved by Veth and taken into her possession. He has no desire to remember the life of the person who ended up buried where he woke up, [25] though he has expressed some regret at not experiencing a childhood.

Entertainer, fighter, and performer, “Molly” has a knack for hiding his true self behind the shifting color and shape of a personality he seems to wear like his singular coat. Beau told Molly she once found out a politician and his wife were both cheating on each other then used that information to ruin their relationship and their lives. Inspired by his signature coat, the lightweight, unisex, button down shirt is patterned with a vibrantly colorful design representative of Mollymauk Tealeaf ’s flamboyant and enigmatic nature. Lucien indicated to the Mighty Nein that Mollymauk means nothing to him, although he understood their grief.